Paramount Plus has confirmed that the Duttons will be back for a second season of their origin story, 1923. The scripts are still being written, and filming has not yet started, so it's likely that fans will have to wait until early 2024 for season two. Harrison Ford has confirmed that he will be returning as patriarch Jacob Dutton, and Helen Mirren is also set to reprise her role as Cara.

The plot of season two is unknown, but the first season ended with the Duttons facing an uncertain future as they struggle to pay their property taxes. The fallout from Arthur's death is also likely to follow Alexandra and Spencer into the new season. Fans have expressed their hope to see more of the Dutton family and Teonna in season two.